Question
Assalamu Alaikum, I am a male revert living with a hostile Hindu family in Canada. I converted in December 2024 and practice Islam entirely in secret. My family does not know I am Muslim. If I begin fasting, my family will notice I am not eating during the day, which will expose my Islam. My father is extremely hostile toward Islam and has a pattern of financial control. If he finds out, he may refuse to pay for my education, which I depend on entirely as I am a full-time student with no income for the next 18 months. I also cannot wake up for Suhoor or adjust my eating schedule without raising suspicion. My questions: 1. Am I exempt from fasting this Ramadan given my need to conceal my faith under duress? 2. If exempt, do I make up the fasts later (Qada) when my situation changes, or do I pay Fidyah? 3. Is it sinful that I have not fasted this Ramadan given my circumstances? JazakAllah Khair.
Islamic Ruling & Answer
VerifiedWalekumussalam,
(1) If a person is in an environment where revealing their Islam may lead to serious harm, such as a real risk to their life, wealth, or essential life matters (like education), then Islamic jurisprudence recognizes such compulsion as a valid excuse. In such a situation, the Shariah takes into account the need to protect a person from severe hardship and harm. Therefore, if there is a strong likelihood that fasting will expose one’s Islam and cause significant harm, it is permissible to temporarily refrain from fasting. However, the importance and sanctity of fasting should remain in the heart, and one should intend to fulfill this obligation when the opportunity arises.
(2) In this case, Fidyah is not required; rather, Qada (making up the missed fasts later) will be necessary. This means that when circumstances improve and you are able to fast freely, you should make up for the number of fasts missed during this Ramadan.
(3) If there is genuine compulsion and a real fear of harm, and the fasts are missed because of that, then there is no sin. This is because Islamic law takes necessity and compulsion into consideration. However, once the situation becomes favorable, it will be necessary to make up those missed fasts.
However, it should be clearly understood that this permission applies only if there is a real and serious fear of harm from the parents, as described in the question. If, in reality, there is no strong likelihood of severe hardship or harm from revealing your Islam or from fasting, then it would not be permissible to leave the fasts, and in that case you would be required to observe them.
May Allah make your situation easy, protect your faith, and grant you strength and steadfastness.
Answered by
Mufti Tosif Qasmi
March 13, 2026
Related Questions
حكم الصيام عند نزول قطرات بنية في أيام
Fasting Without Suhoor and Lying About It
Maal hone ke bawajood hajj na karne ka hukm
Zakat on Installment Properties
مسجد کے چندے اور محتاجوں میں ترجیح کا مسئلہ
Brown Discharge During Menses