Question
My sister-in-law does not observe pardah and does not cover her head or wear a scarf. Would I be sinful if I requested a separate living arrangement or maintained boundaries, as my daughters are growing up and I do not want them to be influenced? My intention is not to cut ties or disrespect her, but only to protect my childrenโs upbringing while maintaining family relations.
Islamic Ruling & Answer
VerifiedIf the situation is truly as described in the question, and there are no additional details that would change the ruling, then seeking a separate living arrangement or maintaining appropriate boundaries solely to protect your daughters' Islamic and moral upbringing is not, in itself, sinful. Parents have a duty to safeguard their children's faith, modesty, and character. Therefore, if there is a genuine concern that a particular environment may negatively influence their upbringing, it is permissible to take reasonable steps to protect them, provided this does not involve injustice, mistreatment, or severing family ties.
Accordingly, if your intention is only to protect your children's upbringing not to humiliate your sister-in-law or cut off family relations then, in principle, requesting separate accommodation or maintaining appropriate boundaries is permissible. At the same time, you should continue to treat your sister-in-law with kindness and respect, uphold family ties, and, where appropriate, advise her gently and wisely about the importance of modesty.
Answered by
Mufti Tosif Qasmi
June 28, 2026
Related Questions
Can a Wife Ask for Divorce If Her Husband Marries Again?
Is Iddah Required After Divorce Before Rukhsati?
Can a Non-Mahram Sleep in the Same Room as You?
Can I Help My Brother Financially After Fulfilling My Familyโs Needs ?
What Is a Conditional Talaq in Islam?
Can I Still Demand Repayment After Forgiving Someoneโs Debt?
Support AskMuftiOnline
Your contribution helps scholars answer more questions and keeps this platform free for everyone.
Contribute Now